Fair Reasons for Dismissal: reasons other than misconduct

This is the third in a series of articles discussing Fair Reasons for Dismissal and Unfair Dismissal. For a dismissal to be fair it must be based on one of five reasons, the second article discussed the Fair Process for a Misconduct Dismissal and this article we will take a brief look at the remaining four reasons.

Capability or Ability To Do The Job

This is where the employee is failing to reach minimum acceptable standards or they can’t do the job properly, for instance they don’t have the right qualifications. Adequate training is the critical consideration in these situations.

Where, despite providing extra training, the employee’s performance continues to be below the minimum acceptable standards you should discuss this with them, making it clear which areas are unsatisfactory and explain your expectations for improvement. You should always allow them time to improve before taking action to dismiss. Examples of the type of behaviour that would warrant a capability dismissal include:

  • Failure to keep up to date with technological changes to their job
  • Failure to get along with colleagues
  • Long-term or persistent illness making it impossible for them to do their job

Dismissals relating to illness are difficult and there are many alternatives which should be considered before reaching a decision to dismiss. If the employee has a disability, such as a long-term illness, you have a legal duty to try to find a way round the problem, including making ‘reasonable adjustments’ to how and/or where you work.


There is a strict statutory framework which must be followed when a redundancy situation applies.

I am often asked ‘can’t I just make him redundant?’ and my answer is always ‘No!’. Redundancy should never be viewed as an easy option to dismiss an employ who is not performing for one reason or another.

To begin with the employees concerned must be redundant within the definition of the term in the Employment Rights Act 1996:-

  • The employer has ceased, or intends to cease, to carry on the business for the purpose of which the employee was so employed.
  • The employer has ceased, or intends to cease, to carry on the business in the place where the employee was employed to work.
  • The requirements of the business for the employee to carry out work of a particular kind or for employees to carry out work of a particular king in the place where the employee was employed by the employer have ceased or diminished, or are expected to cease or diminish.

The test usually used by Tribunals is:-

  • Do any of the definitions set out above exist?
  • If so, is the dismissal wholly or mainly attributable to that state of affairs?

In addition to the above reasons, the dismissals must be reasonable.

The reason(s) for a redundancy situation can occur through any number of factors, such as economic viability of the business, technical change or organisational re-structuring of the business.

A Statutory Restriction

Dismissal can take place if continuing to employ would break the law i.e. a lorry driver loses their driving license.

Some Other Substantial Reason

The emphasis here is on ‘substantial’ and applies to a situation where you have an overwhelming reason why you must dismiss the employee. This should always be a last resort so you need to be able to demonstrate that all other alternatives were considered before choosing to dismiss. Reasons that have previously fallen into this category include:

  • imprisonment
  • an irresolvable personality clash between the employee and a co-worker
  • if the business moves to another location, or if it’s taken over, and it isn’t possible to employ the person because of economic, technical or organisational reasons
  • unreasonably refusing to accept a company reorganisation that changes the employment terms
Library of Essential HR Business Documents
Ready To Go HR Department - policies imageA subscription to my Library of Essential HR Documents provides a ‘Ready To Go HR Department’ that offers simple step by step advice to common HR problems. I like breaking down processes into simple easy to follow steps and have check-lists and templates for absolutely every HR situation you can think of. My easy-to-follow flow charts, meeting scripts, check-lists and template letters ensure everything is done properly, efficiently and compliantly in a professional, friendly and knowledgeable way.

When you join you will receive instant access to:

  • Policies – clearly written and communicated policies are your best defence against tribunal claims.
  • Flowcharts – provide step-by-step guidance to key aspects of HR.
  • Forms and Letters – are templates with clear prompts where text should be added.
  • Meeting Check Lists – provide a reminder of the essential points to be covered in the particular situation.
  • Q&A’s: provide practical solutions to common HR situations.

The Terminating the Employment Relationship folder provides a comprehensive range of documents relating to lay off and short time working, redundancy, providing references for ex-employees and voluntary resignations. There are also a range of How to Guides that deal with unusual situations such as what to do when an employee resigns in the heat of the moments and how to deal with women who are pregnant or on maternity leave when you are making staff redundant.

Fair Reasons for Dismissal: reasons other than misconduct

Let Me Buy You A Coffee!

If you found this helpful and you would like to learn more about how I work with owners of small business who want to improve their HR management, please go here.

Tap into and share the Kea world!

Don't forget to add Kea to your social networks and when you read an article that you like share it with your network!