Managing Employee Attendance

A Practical Guide To Managing Sickness Absence, Attendance Concerns And Employee Well-being

Managing employee attendance is an important part of running any business. Employees will inevitably need time away from work because of illness, but frequent or prolonged absence can affect productivity, increase pressure on colleagues and become difficult to manage if concerns are not addressed early.

Effective attendance management is not about penalising employees for being genuinely unwell. It is about recording and monitoring absence consistently, understanding the reasons behind it, providing appropriate support and addressing attendance concerns fairly when they arise.

For SMEs in particular, even one employee being absent can have a significant impact on the rest of the team. Having clear absence reporting procedures, holding return-to-work discussions and identifying patterns or concerns early can help prevent relatively straightforward attendance issues becoming much more difficult to manage.

This guide explains how employers can manage employee attendance effectively, from recording and monitoring sickness absence through to supporting long-term absence, considering reasonable adjustments and deciding when formal action may be appropriate.

What Does Managing Employee Attendance Involve?

Attendance management is the process employers use to record, monitor and manage employee absence whilst supporting employees who are unable to attend work because of ill health. A good attendance management process combines clear procedures with regular communication and appropriate support.

Managing employee attendance effectively usually involves:

• Having a clear procedure for employees to report sickness absence.
• Recording absence accurately and consistently.
• Keeping appropriate contact with employees during periods of absence.
• Holding return-to-work discussions following sickness absence.
• Monitoring attendance and identifying patterns or recurring concerns.
• Discussing attendance concerns with employees rather than allowing problems to continue.
• Considering whether an underlying health condition or disability may be affecting attendance.
• Providing appropriate support and considering reasonable adjustments where necessary.
• Seeking medical or Occupational Health advice where further information would help.
• Using a fair formal procedure where attendance remains unsatisfactory despite appropriate support.

The aim is not to achieve zero sickness absence. Employees will become ill and there will be occasions when they are genuinely unable to work. Effective attendance management helps employers distinguish between ordinary sickness absence, situations where an employee needs additional support and attendance patterns that may require further management action.

Why Managing Employee Attendance Matters

Employee absence is a normal part of working life, but when absence becomes frequent, prolonged or difficult to predict it can have a significant impact on a small business. Managing employee attendance consistently helps employers understand what is happening, provide appropriate support and address concerns before they become more difficult to manage.

Effective attendance management can help employers:

• Reduce disruption to the business by identifying attendance concerns early and planning how workloads will be managed during periods of absence.
• Support employees appropriately by recognising when ill health, disability, workplace stress or other circumstances may be affecting attendance.
• Identify patterns of absence that may otherwise be missed, such as repeated short-term absence, particular days of the week or absence linked to workplace issues.
• Ensure employees are treated consistently by following the same reporting, recording and review procedures across the business.
• Reduce pressure on colleagues who may otherwise have to absorb additional work or provide repeated absence cover.
• Make better management decisions by using accurate attendance records, conversations with the employee and, where appropriate, medical evidence.
• Reduce legal risk by considering issues such as disability, reasonable adjustments and discrimination before taking formal action.

For smaller businesses, the impact can be particularly noticeable. If one person is regularly absent from a team of six, colleagues may quickly find themselves covering additional duties, deadlines may be affected and managers can spend increasing amounts of time arranging cover and reorganising work.

Good attendance management provides a framework for dealing with these situations fairly. It allows employers to balance the needs of the employee with the operational needs of the business rather than allowing absence to drift unmanaged.

Recording And Monitoring Employee Absence

Accurate absence records are the foundation of effective attendance management. If sickness absence is recorded inconsistently, employers may struggle to identify patterns, understand the extent of an attendance problem or demonstrate that employees have been treated fairly.

Employers should have a consistent process for recording sickness absence, including:

• The date the absence started and ended.
• The number of working days or hours lost.
• The reason given for the absence.
• Whether the employee followed the company’s absence reporting procedure.
• Whether self-certification or a fit note was required and received.
• Any return-to-work discussion that took place.
• Any agreed support, adjustments or follow-up action.

Recording individual absences is only part of the process. Employers should also review attendance records periodically so that repeated short-term absence, increasing levels of absence or other patterns can be identified and discussed with the employee.

Good records can also help managers distinguish between different types of absence. For example, repeated short-term sickness may require a different management approach from a single period of long-term absence, whilst disability-related absence may require consideration of reasonable adjustments.

Information about an employee’s health is sensitive personal information and should be handled appropriately. Access to sickness records should therefore be restricted to those who genuinely need the information, and employers should avoid recording unnecessary medical detail.

Clear Absence Reporting Procedures help ensure managers receive the information they need and that sickness absence is recorded consistently from the first day.

Identifying Patterns Of Absence

Reviewing absence records regularly can help employers identify patterns that may not be obvious when individual periods of sickness are considered in isolation. A pattern does not necessarily mean there is a problem, but it can indicate that a conversation with the employee would be helpful.

Patterns employers may notice include:

• Frequent short periods of sickness absence.
• Repeated absence on particular days of the week, such as Mondays or Fridays.
• Absence immediately before or after weekends, bank holidays or booked annual leave.
• Repeated absence around particular shifts, duties or working arrangements.
• An increasing frequency or duration of sickness absence.
• Absence occurring at particular times of the year.
• Repeated absences attributed to the same or similar health problem.
• Absence that appears to coincide with workplace events, deadlines, meetings or periods of increased workload.

The existence of a pattern should not lead managers to assume that an employee is abusing the sickness absence procedure. There may be a perfectly legitimate explanation. For example, recurring absence could indicate an underlying health condition, disability, caring difficulties, workplace stress or another issue that the employer was previously unaware of.

Where a pattern is identified, the appropriate next step is normally to discuss it with the employee. Managers can explain what the attendance records show, ask whether there is an underlying reason for the pattern and explore whether any support or further action may be appropriate.

Keeping accurate records of these discussions is also important. If attendance concerns continue, previous conversations, support offered and any agreed actions will provide useful information when deciding what should happen next.

Having An Attendance Conversation

When an employee’s attendance gives cause for concern, the first step will often be a conversation. This does not necessarily need to be a formal meeting. An early, constructive discussion can help the manager understand what is happening and identify whether any support or further action is needed.

The conversation should be based on the employee’s actual attendance record rather than assumptions. Explain what you have noticed, give the employee an opportunity to respond and listen carefully to any explanation they provide.

Depending on the circumstances, managers may want to discuss:

• The employee’s recent attendance record and any patterns or concerns identified.
• The reasons for the absence and whether there is an underlying health issue.
• Whether anything at work may be contributing to the employee’s absence.
• Whether the employee expects the problem to continue or further absence is likely.
• Whether any temporary support or workplace adjustments may help.
• Whether medical or Occupational Health advice would be useful.
• Any impact the absence is having on the employee’s role or the wider team.
• What happens next and whether attendance will be reviewed again after an agreed period.

Managers should approach the discussion with an open mind. What initially appears to be an attendance problem may reveal an underlying health condition, disability, workplace stress, caring difficulty or another issue that requires a different response.

Equally, being supportive does not mean employers cannot address unacceptable levels of attendance. Where absence is having a significant impact on the business, it is reasonable to explain those concerns clearly and discuss what improvement may be required. The important point is that any expectations and next steps should reflect the individual circumstances rather than being predetermined before the conversation takes place.

A brief written record should be kept of the discussion, including any explanation provided by the employee, support considered, actions agreed and when the situation will next be reviewed.

Managing Frequent Short-Term Absence

Frequent short-term sickness absence can be particularly difficult for employers to manage. Each individual absence may only last a day or two, but repeated absences can create significant disruption, particularly in a small team where colleagues may regularly have to provide cover at short notice.

Employers should avoid assuming that frequent absence means an employee is not genuinely ill. At the same time, genuine sickness does not mean that attendance concerns should simply be left unmanaged. The employer still needs to understand what is causing the absence, consider whether support is appropriate and assess the impact of the employee’s overall attendance on the business.

Where short-term absence becomes frequent, employers should:

• Review the employee’s attendance record and identify the frequency, duration and reasons for absence.
• Hold return-to-work discussions consistently following periods of sickness absence.
• Discuss any patterns or concerns with the employee and give them an opportunity to explain.
• Ask whether there is an underlying health condition contributing to the absences.
• Consider whether the employee may have a disability and whether reasonable adjustments could help.
• Explore whether workplace factors, including workload, working relationships or stress, may be contributing to the problem.
• Consider obtaining medical or Occupational Health advice where further information would assist.
• Explain the impact that the level of absence is having on the business where this has become a concern.
• Agree what happens next, including any support, expectations and a suitable review period.

It is important to look at the circumstances behind the absences rather than simply counting the number of occasions. Five unrelated minor illnesses may require a different response from five absences connected to the same long-term health condition. Similarly, disability-related absence may need to be considered differently when applying attendance triggers or deciding whether formal action is appropriate.

Where appropriate support has been provided but the employee’s attendance remains at a level the business cannot reasonably sustain, it may eventually be appropriate to move into a formal attendance or capability process. Any formal action should be based on the individual circumstances and follow a fair procedure.

Managing Long-Term Sickness Absence

Long-term sickness absence requires a different approach from frequent short-term absence. Rather than focusing primarily on the number of absences, employers need to understand the employee’s health situation, likely timescale for recovery and whether there are practical steps that could support a return to work.

One of the most common mistakes employers make is allowing long-term absence to drift. Managers may be reluctant to contact an employee who is unwell because they do not want to appear unsympathetic or put them under pressure. However, appropriate and supportive contact is an important part of managing long-term sickness absence.

Employers should normally:

• Maintain reasonable contact with the employee throughout their absence.
• Agree how and how often contact will take place, taking account of the employee’s circumstances.
• Keep up-to-date information about the employee’s health and likely return-to-work timescale.
• Discuss whether anything at work may be affecting the employee’s health or ability to return.
• Consider whether the employee may have a disability and whether reasonable adjustments may be required.
• Seek appropriate medical or Occupational Health advice where further information would help with decision-making.
• Consider whether a phased return, temporary changes to duties, altered hours or other adjustments could support a return to work.
• Hold review meetings where appropriate and keep a record of discussions, medical information and agreed actions.
• Review the operational impact of the continuing absence and the business’s ability to sustain it.

The level and frequency of contact should be appropriate to the circumstances. An employee recovering from planned surgery may need a different approach from someone absent with work-related stress or a serious long-term health condition. Employers should avoid both extremes: contacting an employee so frequently that they feel pressured, or having no meaningful contact for months.

As the absence continues, employers will usually need increasingly clear information about the employee’s prognosis. A fit note provides useful information, but it may not answer the practical questions the employer needs to consider. An Occupational Health assessment can help establish likely return-to-work timescales, possible restrictions, reasonable adjustments and whether further medical review may be appropriate.

Where a return to work appears possible, the employer should explore what may help the employee return safely and successfully. This could include a phased return, temporary changes to duties or hours, workplace adjustments or regular reviews during the employee’s return.

Sometimes, despite appropriate support and reasonable attempts to facilitate a return, an employee may remain unable to return to their role within a timescale the business can reasonably sustain. In those circumstances, a formal capability process may eventually need to be considered. Dismissal should never be the automatic consequence of long-term sickness absence and employers should ensure they have appropriate medical information, have considered reasonable adjustments and have followed a fair process before reaching that stage.

Reasonable Adjustments And Employee Attendance

Where an employee’s attendance is affected by a health condition, employers should consider whether the employee may be disabled under the Equality Act 2010 and whether reasonable adjustments could help them remain at work, return to work or improve their attendance.

An employee does not necessarily need to use the word “disabled” or provide a formal diagnosis before an employer should start considering the issue. If the employer knows, or could reasonably be expected to know, that the employee may have a disability, it may need to explore whether adjustments are appropriate.

Depending on the employee’s circumstances and their role, reasonable adjustments could include:

• Adjusting working hours, start or finish times.
• Allowing additional or more frequent breaks.
• Temporarily or permanently changing particular duties.
• Providing equipment or making changes to the physical workplace.
• Adjusting working arrangements or, where appropriate, considering home or hybrid working.
• Allowing time away from work for treatment, rehabilitation or medical appointments.
• Adjusting absence triggers or considering disability-related absence separately where appropriate.
• Providing additional supervision, support or regular review meetings.

What is reasonable will depend on the individual circumstances. An adjustment that is straightforward for one business may not be practical for another. Employers can consider factors such as how effective the adjustment is likely to be, its cost, the resources available to the business, the impact on colleagues and customers and whether there are other practical ways of removing or reducing the disadvantage.

Adjustments should also be reviewed. An arrangement that is helpful while an employee is recovering may no longer be needed after a few weeks, whilst an employee with a long-term condition may require an adjustment on an ongoing basis. Keeping the arrangement under review allows the employer and employee to establish whether it is actually working.

Where the employer does not have enough information to understand how a health condition affects the employee’s ability to work, medical or Occupational Health advice may help identify appropriate adjustments and any restrictions that should be considered.

When Occupational Health May Help

Managers are not expected to make medical judgements about an employee’s health. Where sickness absence becomes prolonged, recurring or difficult to manage, Occupational Health can provide independent medical advice to help the employer understand how the employee’s health may affect their ability to work.

An Occupational Health referral may be particularly useful where:

• An employee has been absent for a prolonged period and there is uncertainty about when they may be able to return.
• Frequent short-term absences may be connected to an underlying health condition.
• The employer needs advice about whether an employee is fit to carry out some or all of their duties.
• A health condition may amount to a disability under the Equality Act 2010.
• The employer needs guidance about possible reasonable adjustments or workplace restrictions.
• A phased return or temporary change to duties or working hours is being considered.
• An employee has returned to work but continues to experience difficulties because of their health.
• The employer is considering formal capability action and requires up-to-date medical information before making decisions.

The quality of the advice received will often depend on the information provided to Occupational Health and the questions the employer asks. A well-prepared referral should explain the employee’s role, the attendance concerns, any support already provided and the specific questions the employer needs medical advice to help answer.

Occupational Health provides advice rather than making the management decision. The employer must consider the report alongside the employee’s circumstances, the requirements of the role and the needs of the business before deciding what happens next.

Not sure whether Occupational Health is the right next step? Our When Should SMEs Use Occupational Health? guide explains when a referral may be appropriate, how the process works, what questions to ask and how to use the resulting report.

Using Attendance Triggers

Attendance triggers can help employers identify when an employee’s level of sickness absence should be reviewed. They provide managers with a consistent prompt to look more closely at an employee’s attendance rather than relying on individual judgement about when absence has become a concern.

A trigger might be reached because an employee has had a particular number of separate absences, exceeded a certain number of sickness days or reached a specified score under a system such as the Bradford Factor.

However, reaching an attendance trigger should not automatically result in a warning. The trigger tells the manager that the employee’s attendance needs to be reviewed; it does not determine what the outcome of that review should be.

When a trigger is reached, employers should consider:

• The number, frequency and duration of the employee’s absences.
• The reasons given for each period of absence.
• Whether there is a pattern that requires further discussion.
• Whether the absences may be connected to an underlying health condition or disability.
• Whether disability-related absence needs to be considered differently.
• Whether reasonable adjustments have been considered or implemented.
• Whether Occupational Health or other medical advice would help.
• Any previous attendance discussions, support or agreed actions.
• The impact the level of absence is having on the business.

Attendance triggers should also be applied consistently, but consistency does not necessarily mean treating every employee identically. Two employees may reach exactly the same trigger but have very different circumstances and therefore require different management responses.

The Bradford Factor can be useful for highlighting frequent short-term absence because it gives greater weight to repeated occasions of absence. However, a Bradford Factor score should be treated as management information rather than a decision-making tool. Employers should not use a particular score as an automatic threshold for issuing warnings or taking other formal action.

Used properly, attendance triggers provide an early warning system. Used too rigidly, they can result in employers overlooking important information about health, disability or the reasons behind an employee’s absence.

When Formal Action May Be Appropriate

There may come a point where informal discussions, support and monitoring have not resulted in a sustainable level of attendance. In these circumstances, it may be appropriate to move into a formal attendance or capability process.

Formal action should not simply follow automatically because an employee has reached an attendance trigger. Before progressing, employers should understand the reasons for the absence, consider any relevant medical information and ensure that appropriate support and reasonable adjustments have been explored.

Formal action may be appropriate where:

• Frequent short-term absence continues despite previous attendance discussions and support.
• The employee’s level of attendance is having a significant and ongoing impact on the business.
• Attendance has been reviewed over an appropriate period but concerns remain.
• An employee remains on long-term sickness absence and there is no clear or reasonably foreseeable return to work.
• Medical or Occupational Health advice indicates that the employee may be unable to return to their existing role.
• Reasonable adjustments and other possible ways of supporting the employee have been considered but have not resolved the attendance or capability concerns.

A formal attendance or capability process will usually involve explaining the concerns to the employee, reviewing their attendance and any medical information, considering their explanation and discussing what improvement, support or further review may be appropriate. The employee should understand what is expected, how their attendance will be reviewed and the possible consequences if the situation does not improve.

Where long-term ill health is involved, employers should be particularly careful before considering dismissal. Up-to-date medical information may be required and the employer should consider the likely prognosis, reasonable adjustments, possible alternative work and whether it is reasonable to wait any longer for the employee to return.

In some circumstances, continued unsatisfactory attendance may ultimately result in dismissal on capability grounds. However, dismissal should normally be the end of a fair process rather than the starting point. The employer should be able to demonstrate what information was considered, what support was explored and why continued employment could no longer reasonably be sustained.

It is also important to distinguish sickness absence from conduct. An employee should not normally be disciplined simply because they are genuinely unwell. However, separate conduct concerns may arise if, for example, an employee repeatedly fails to follow the company’s absence reporting procedure without good reason, provides misleading information or fails to maintain required contact during their absence.

Common Attendance Management Mistakes

Attendance management can become difficult when employers wait too long to address concerns or apply procedures too rigidly. Many problems can be avoided by keeping accurate records, communicating regularly and dealing with concerns as they arise.

Common mistakes include:

• Waiting until absence becomes a serious problem. Small patterns of absence can develop into much larger attendance concerns when they are not discussed early.
• Failing to record absence consistently. Without accurate records, it becomes difficult to identify patterns, apply procedures fairly or demonstrate the impact absence is having on the business.
• Not holding return-to-work discussions. These conversations provide an opportunity to understand the reason for absence, identify support that may be needed and spot recurring concerns.
• Assuming repeated absence is not genuine. A pattern may justify further discussion, but it does not prove that an employee is abusing the sickness procedure.
• Using attendance triggers as automatic warning points. A trigger should prompt a review of the employee’s attendance and circumstances rather than determine the outcome.
• Treating every employee exactly the same. Consistency is important, but different circumstances may require different responses, particularly where disability or an underlying health condition is involved.
• Allowing long-term sickness absence to drift. Avoiding contact because an employee is unwell can leave both parties uncertain about what is happening and make an eventual return to work more difficult to manage.
• Waiting for the employee to request reasonable adjustments. Employers may need to explore adjustments proactively where they know, or could reasonably be expected to know, that an employee has a disability.
• Making medical assumptions. Managers should not try to diagnose employees or decide for themselves what someone should or should not be capable of doing. Where medical information is needed, appropriate advice should be obtained.
• Moving to formal action without sufficient warning. Employees should normally already understand that their attendance is causing concern, what improvement is expected and what may happen if the situation does not improve.
• Confusing sickness absence with misconduct. Genuine sickness absence is generally an attendance or capability issue. A separate conduct issue may arise where an employee fails to follow reporting procedures or is dishonest, but the two should not automatically be treated as the same thing.
• Focusing only on the employee and forgetting the business. Employers should provide appropriate support, but they are also entitled to consider the operational impact of absence and what the business can reasonably sustain.

How Kea HR Can Help

Managing employee attendance can become complicated surprisingly quickly. What starts as a few days of sickness absence can develop into questions about underlying health conditions, reasonable adjustments, Occupational Health, capability or whether the business can continue to sustain the level of absence.

Kea HR provides practical attendance management support to SMEs, helping you understand what needs to happen next and ensuring employees are treated fairly and consistently.

We can help with:

• Attendance management procedures – developing clear and practical processes for reporting, recording and managing sickness absence.
• Attendance concerns – reviewing absence records, identifying patterns and helping managers prepare for attendance conversations.
• Return-to-work meetings – helping managers hold effective discussions following sickness absence and identify any further action or support required.
• Long-term sickness absence – managing communication, review meetings and the practical steps required during prolonged absence.
• Occupational Health referrals – deciding whether a referral is appropriate, preparing effective referral questions and helping you understand and implement the recommendations.
• Reasonable adjustments – identifying practical adjustments and helping you consider your responsibilities under the Equality Act 2010.
• Attendance and capability procedures – supporting you where attendance remains unsatisfactory despite appropriate management and support.
• HR software – helping you introduce systems such as Breathe HR to record absence, monitor attendance and give managers better visibility of employee records.

Whether you need advice about one employee or want to improve the way absence is managed across your business, Kea HR can provide as much or as little support as you need.

Need Help Managing Employee Attendance?

If sickness absence is becoming difficult to manage, you don’t need to wait until the situation becomes a formal problem.

Kea HR can help you review what has happened, identify the appropriate next steps and manage the situation fairly and practically. Speak directly with our CIPD-qualified HR expert with 30+ years’ experience.

Book Your Free Intro Call

Get the Latest Legislation News and My Top Tips delivered straight to your inbox

Have a question? Let's have a chat and a coffee!

If you found this helpful and you would like to learn more about how I work with owners of small business who want to improve their HR management, please book some time in my diary.

Tap into and share the Kea world!

Don't forget to add Kea to your social networks and when you read an article that you like share it with your network!