Collective redundancies need not be at one establishment

Subject to any further appeal, this case brings about a major change to collective redundancy law.

Historically where employers have proposed redundancies at different geographical sites within its business, they have treated each site as “one establishment” for the purposes of determining whether collective consultation is required. This has meant that an employer would only have to enter into collective consultation with bigger sites where 20 or more employees were to be made redundant, therefore avoiding collective consultation at smaller sites or indeed avoiding collective consultation altogether. This new interpretation of the legislation will mean that collective redundancies need not be at one establishment. Employers will have to look at the wider picture and avoid focussing on any one site when deciding upon the consultation process which should be implemented.

The Decision

Under section 188(1) of Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992 (“TULCRA”), employers are obliged to collectively consult where they propose to dismiss as redundant 20 or more employees “at one establishment” within a period of 90 days or less. Where an employer fails to inform or consult an Employment Tribunal may order an employer to pay a protective award to its employees (up to a maximum of 90 days’ pay).

In USDAW and others v WW Realisation 1 Ltd (in Liquidation) and another when Woolworths (and Ethel Austin) became insolvent in 2008, claims for protective awards were brought by the union on behalf of former employees. An Employment Tribunal held that each store was a separate establishment, and consequently, the duty of collective consultation was not triggered in stores where fewer than 20 employees were to be made redundant. Therefore, those employees did not receive a protective award.

The Union appealed on behalf of the employees who did not receive a protective award. It argued that the term “at one establishment” was incompatible with the underlying EU Directive and left workers vulnerable to redundancy without fair consultation.

The EAT found in favour of the trade union and overturned the Employment Tribunal’s decision that each store was a separate establishment for the purposes of TULCRA. Therefore, all of the employees from the smaller stores (3,233 at Woolworths and 1,210 at Ethel Austin) will now be entitled to a protective award.

The EAT judgement concluded that: “The simple proposition we have recorded is there should be some interpretation to yield the outcome that the obligation arises when 20 or more are to be dismissed irrespective of where they work”. They ultimately held that the words “at one establishment” should be deleted from 188(1) of TULRCA.

Implications

This decision is highly significant as it changes the face of UK redundancy law and potentially significantly extends an employer’s collective consultation obligations.

Furthermore, it is important to remember that the collective consultation duty does not just apply to redundancy. It can also apply to situations such as changes to terms and conditions which would result in dismissal.

Library of Essential HR Business Documents
Ready To Go HR Department - policies imageA subscription to my Library of Essential HR Documents provides a ‘Ready To Go HR Department’ that offers simple step by step advice to common HR problems. I like breaking down processes into simple easy to follow steps and have check-lists and templates for absolutely every HR situation you can think of. My easy-to-follow flow charts, meeting scripts, check-lists and template letters ensure everything is done properly, efficiently and compliantly in a professional, friendly and knowledgeable way.

When you join you will receive instant access to:

  • Policies – clearly written and communicated policies are your best defence against tribunal claims.
  • Flowcharts – provide step-by-step guidance to key aspects of HR.
  • Forms and Letters – are templates with clear prompts where text should be added.
  • Meeting Check Lists – provide a reminder of the essential points to be covered in the particular situation.
  • Q&A’s: provide practical solutions to common HR situations.

The Terminating the Employment Relationship folder provides a comprehensive range of documents relating to lay off and short time working, redundancy, providing references for ex-employees and voluntary resignations. There are also a range of How to Guides that deal with unusual situations such as what to do when an employee resigns in the heat of the moments and how to deal with women who are pregnant or on maternity leave when you are making staff redundant.

Collective redundancies need not be at one establishment

Let Me Buy You A Coffee!

If you found this helpful and you would like to learn more about how I work with owners of small business who want to improve their HR management, please go here.

Tap into and share the Kea world!

Don't forget to add Kea to your social networks and when you read an article that you like share it with your network!